Saturday, December 01, 2007

Themes emerging from the discussion of blogs as scholarship

Blogging on Peer-Reviewed Research This is part 4 of a multi-part post on the subject of blogs as scholarship. It is the first part of the discussion of the themes that emerged in the journal and law review literature. The last post introduced this section. The next section continues with the themes that emerged from the discussion.

Themes emerging from the discussion of blogs as scholarship

Blogs fit within existing arrays. Blogs enter an ongoing conversation. Scholars communicate in a wide variety of ways, for different purposes, and with the intention to reach different audiences. Thus, many authors start their essays by describing where they believe blogs fit within the existing arrays of academic duties and communication options.

Herring et al., assessing blogs generally (not focusing on whether they constitute scholarship), situated blogs among pre-existing off-line genres (diaries, travel logs, letters to the editor) and related Web-based genres (home pages), concluding that blogs are neither Web-natives nor particularly unique, but are hybrids of off-line and online precursors (2005, p. 160). They identified several characteristics of blogs that nevertheless have the potential to change the way we think about the Web:

  • blogs allow instant publishing without knowledge of hypertext markup language,
  • facilitate interactivity, even if not fully utilized today, and
  • can be used in a variety of ways depending on their owners’ desires (p. 162).

These same themes appear in the literature about legal blogs as scholarship, reported below.

Saper places blogs within “a larger process of rhetorical invention … which includes wikis, audio, Flash, tagging, AJAX-driven systems, database-run systems, etc.” (2006, par. 12).

In 2006, Harvard Law School held a Symposium on Bloggership: How blogs are transforming legal scholarship (hereafter, Bloggership). The Washington University Law Review collected the papers in volume 84, number 6, published only just this month (November 16, 2007). Twenty-three panelists discussed a wide variety of topics. Twenty-two of the panelists were bloggers. In his short conference paper, Eugene Volokh situates blogging among the three responsibilities of academics (cite). These include dissemination, discovery (constituting the core of scholarship) and "doing things," which, in the field of law includes activities that change law, litigating cases, or consulting on cases, among other undertakings (cite). He notes that dissemination to the public was not a high priority or a big part of most academics' lives in the past. They spent most of their time discovering and doing. But blogging is changing that for Volokh and others like him who see the reach of their blogs far exceeding the reach of their law review articles (cite). He believes, however, that one really only has the choice to spend more time disseminating knowledge publicly after one has tenure (cite). Notably, other pre-tenure Bloggership participants disagreed with this conclusion (Hurt & Yin, 2006).

Kate Litvak (2006), a widely acknowledged blog skeptic (and the only Bloggership panelist who is not a blogger), is totally unimpressed. This U.T. Law professor situates the blog within a milieu of significant changes in legal scholarship over the last couple of decades and concludes that a blog’s importance pales in comparison (p. 5):

[L]ots of new developments have been transforming legal scholarship lately. New technologies. Availability of data. Rapid distribution of current research. Co-authorship. Growing ties with other disciplines. The influx of people with Ph.D-level training. Increasing compartmentalization and specialization of academic disciplines. Rise of resource-intensive fields. The shift of practitioner-oriented work to practitioner authors. Internationalization of scholarship and faculties. As compared to all this, how important do you think blogs are?

Blogs can be synergistic with other academic duties. Volokh explores how bloggers may achieve synergism with discovery and doing, to avoid an "either/or" choice. For example, he believes being a well-known blogger enhances success when submitting an article to a journal, and increases the chances of receiving invitations to symposia, to work on legislative proposals and to consult on important cases, all examples of scholarship and doing. He also suggests that bloggers should serialize their drafts for comment on their blogs, find key nuggets from older works that might be new to many in the lay blog audience and summarize them on blogs, and use blogs to solicit examples to support arguments the scholar needs to make. He concludes by observing that blogging about current cases can very directly affect the development of law (that is, doing) if a judge reads and uses the scholar’s blog posts, and that micro-discoveries (small instances of applying law to a new situation) can be blogged quickly and effectively, thus placing discovery on the blog itself.

Dan Berman also sees synergistic advantage for blogs. He believes blogging can reconnect scholarship with teaching and service, where the ultra-long law review article threatens to sever the link (cite). He believes that blogging facilitates all three of his responsibilities to the academy and, at the same time, fosters collaboration and makes it easier to update casebooks and treatises. For example, Bill Patry has a blog devoted to updating his year-old, seven-volume copyright treatise, in which he sets forth his lines of reasoning on changes he is considering for the treatise (2007).

Essential blog features include blog form and content, temporality, and a potentially broad audience. Saper’s report highlights one of the most frequently discussed blog qualities, quoting a series of authors comparing the ways they express themselves on their blogs and in their formal academic writing. They vacillate between belief that their blogging style spills over into their academic style, and that if blogs become mainstream, they may lose the informality that attracts many academics (par. 12).

Bloggership panelist Berman (2006) develops his argument, that blogs should be integrated into legal scholarship, in traditional law review article style -- he is logical, methodical, and generously footnotes his work. He believes that the legal academy needs blogs to improve both the form and the content of legal scholarship. He notes that law review articles have become so long and detailed that none but other scholars has the time to read and digest them. Berman agrees with contributor Volokh (2006), that "small ideas," those not justifying a 75 page law review article, should not be turned into a 75 page law review article, but can be more effectively and quickly disseminated by blogging (cite). Linking can replace heavy citation, letting blogs more directly engage with existing scholarship. Berman also notes that as a unique form of communicating, blogging may fit some scholars better than others (cite). He thinks that embracing blogging as legal scholarship will allow some professors who might not otherwise participate to make significant contributions to public discussion. He sees strength in diverse forms of scholarship.

The temporality of blogs is a common theme in discussions of their form and content. Some refer to this quality as “newsiness,” the tendency to build blog posts around the news item, and post frequently. Orin Kerr, for example, believes news is the main niche for blogs: "If you want a running commentary about the latest news in the legal field in short, easily-digestible chunks, blogs are perfect. The popularity of many legal blogs suggests that many people fit this bill" (p. 5). Kerr may be underestimating blog potential when he suggests that the reverse chronological order and newsy-orientation are tyrannical. He believes readers only read the recent posts (p. 4).

On the contrary, it is not a rare reader who investigates a blog’s categories links, or finds older posts directly from Internet searches based on key words. My own blog statistics (Google analytics) suggest that from 1/3 to ½ of readers arrive on particular blog pages from search engines, thus directly accessing older materials. The newsy orientation of blogs may not impede access to more deeply buried materials, anymore than would the location of those same materials in a back issue of a journal.

In a more considered concern, Kerr describes the year-and-a-half mulling over that a good law review article might get, compared to the currency of a blog post (pp. 6-7). Understandably, Kerr cannot see how a blog contributes meaningfully to the former. The assumption that this is what we expect blogs to do is likely in error, however, and further suggests that Kerr defines scholarship narrowly.

Blogs build community and encourage commentary. A common belief about blogs is that they build community – a loyal group of readers who will comment upon the author’s posts (Berman, 2006; Volokh, 2006). Litvak perceives of blogs exclusively in this way, that is, no more than a means to solicit feedback on raw ideas. In her opinion, however, they will fail in this regard because the risk of harm to the scholar in making preliminary statements publicly far outweighs the benefit of commentary and suggestion that cannot be required, but only requested (p. 8):

So, my grand theory has a lemma: blogs cannot turn into cyber-workshops unless they can punish a potential commentator’s silence. And I don’t think they can do that. I also have a corollary: if a blog cannot turn into a real cyber-workshop, the value of keeping exchanges public is not high enough to justify the costs (which are, again, possible embarrassment, understated criticisms, and preemption). Thus, in most cases, bloggers seeking a forum for their early ideas are better off asking for comments privately.

She may be correct that the risks in this area outweigh the benefits for some authors, especially those who envision public communication in such narrow and ego-centric terms. Litvak mentions other possible benefits of blogging only at the end or her article, in an offhand comment ( public dissemination, for example) (p. 9), suggesting that she has not seriously considered broader functionality, or has dismissed it.

Blogs publish instantly. Another important theme is the quickness with which blogs allow their authors to disseminate their ideas, and the benefits of avoiding the lengthy delays of traditional publishing. Volokh observes that blogs raise the pleasure-to-"scutwork" ratio of disseminating publicly: no dealing with editors; no arbitrary word limits; no time delays (cite). Kerr acknowledges the value of being able to just write up a post, hit send, and have the post appear (2006, p. 9), but does not explore the implications of this ability. Recall also that even Leiter, scholarly blog skeptic (though he does blog), acknowledged the benefit of instant publishing (2006, par. 2).

References:

Berman, D. A. (2006, April 2006). Scholarship in action: The power, possibilities and pitfalls for law professor blogs. Public law and legal theory working paper series Retrieved October 9, 2007, from http://ssrn.com/abstract=898174

Herring, S. C., Scheidt, L. A., Wright, E., & Bonus, S. (2005). Weblogs as a bridging genre. Information, Technology and People, 18(2), 142-171.

Hurt, C., & Yin, T. (2006). Blogging While Untenured and Other Extreme Sports. Bloggership: How blogs are transforming legal scholarship Retrieved November 13, 2007, from http://ssrn.com/paper=898046

Kerr, O. S. (2006). Blogs and the legal academy. Paper presented at the Bloggership: How blogs are transforming legal scholarship. Retrieved October 12, 2007, from http://ssrn.com/paper=896994

Leiter, B. (2006). Blogs as scholarship: Conference at Harvard [Blog post]. Brian Leiter's Law School Reports, April 28, 2006. Retrieved November 3, 2007, from http://leiterlawschool.typepad.com/leiter/2006/04/blogs_as_schola.html

Litvak, K. (2006). Blog as a bugged water cooler. Paper presented at the Bloggership: How Blogs are Transforming Legal Scholarship. Retrieved October 12, 2007, from http://ssrn.com/paper=898186

Patry, W. (2007). Chapter 2: Statutory interpretation [Blog post]. Patry Treatise Blog. Retrieved November 13, 2007, from http://patrytreatise.blogspot.com/2007/02/chapter-2-statutory-interpretation.html

Saper, C. (2006). Blogademia. Reconstruction: Studies in contemporary culture Retrieved October 12, 2007, from http://www.reconstruction.eserver.org/064/saper.shtml

Volokh, E. (2006). Scholarship, blogging and trade-offs: On discovering, disseminating and doing. Paper presented at the Bloggership: How blogs are transforming legal scholarship. Retrieved October 10, 2007, from http://ssrn.com/paper=898172

Thursday, November 29, 2007

The scholarly discourse on blogs as scholarship

Blogging on Peer-Reviewed Research This is part 3 of a multi-part post on the subject of blogs as scholarship. It is a short introduction to the discussion of the subject in the journal and law review literature. The last post addressed the blog literature on the subject. The next section indicates the themes that emerged from the discussion, and is quite long soI may need to break it up into 2 parts.

The scholarly discourse

Quantitative research

Scholars begin to address the question of whether blogs are scholarship in journal literature at about the same time they begin to discuss the subject in the blogosphere -- in 2006 -- while general descriptions of blogs appear earlier. In 2005, Herring, Scheidt, Wright and Bonus analyzed blog content and structure, coding 55 features of 203 randomly selected blogs. The authors compared observed characteristics with commonly held beliefs about blogs, and exposed several myths. Seventy percent of their sample consisted of personal blogs; only 12.6% were “filter” blogs, those whose authors link to and comment on other bloggers’ posts. The authors had expected filter blogs to be the most common blog forms (p. 151). Slightly more than half of the blogs surveyed linked to other blogs (p. 154), in sharp contrast to popular belief that linking to other blogs, for example, having a blogroll or other list of recommended blogs, is de rigeur. Most surprising, the average blog entry received .03 comments and the majority of entries received none (p. 156). Further, comparisons of newer entries with older ones suggest that posts do not continue to collect comments; rather, comments occur during a brief period when the post is fresh (p. 156). Fewer than a third of blog posts contain any links to external content at all, this, again, in sharp contrast to the popular perception that blog posts are built around an external link (p. 156).

Herring et al. are notable for reporting an empirical research study even if the sample cannot be said to be representative of the general population. Theirs creates some basis for comparison in later discussion, suggests where research in this area might focus next and lays the groundwork for an understanding of how blogs have come to be considered potentially scholarship at all. I will discuss other of their findings below to illustrate themes that emerge from the literature generally.

Qualitative research

Craig Saper also systematically observed blogs (2006), but focused on the qualities of a small, therefore not likely representative, number of blog posts. He quotes liberally to show how “[t]he blogademia resists the hegemonic academic machine” (par. 2). In short, for Saper, blogs are gossip. But just as quickly as he appears to dismiss blogs, he turns the observation around, suggesting that gossip and scholarly knowledge are more porous categories than we might think (par. 7).

[W]hen academics gossip they may also lead to a new form of knowledge. When bloggers discuss infrastructure (who in your department is an idiot or a psychopath; how poorly the administration of your University functions; or simply the trials and travails of the tenure-track publish or perish mill), they also discuss, unwittingly, the social processes of knowledge production, what counts as scholarship, and discipline formation.

Saper’s short report, other aspects of which I will discuss below, provides a qualitative view of academic blogs and begins to raise the question of whether even in their most banal, they may be scholarship.

References

Herring, S. C., Scheidt, L. A., Wright, E., & Bonus, S. (2005). Weblogs as a bridging genre. Information, Technology and People, 18(2), 142-171.

Saper, C. (2006). Blogademia. Reconstruction: Studies in contemporary culture Retrieved October 12, 2007, from http://www.reconstruction.eserver.org/064/saper.shtml

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Opinion about blogs as scholarship

Blogging on Peer-Reviewed ResearchToday, there is little more than opinion on the question of whether blogs are scholarship and what that might mean. As indicated above, one may observe the discussion about blogs as scholarship in blog posts which may or may not contain scholarly writing; in posts that contain discussions about whether blog posts are scholarship, and finally, in the journal and law review literature. I have only occasionally read posts by law professors that I myself identified as scholarship, but then, what is my definition of scholarship? And whose definition really counts? Ambiguity is part of the current landscape. Few scholars discuss the questions using defined terms. But we can observe at least anecdotally that legal bloggers themselves feel that what they or other bloggers write on their blogs should in appropriate cases be considered scholarship.

Blog posts about blogs as scholarship

I first encountered discussion of blogs as scholarship on blogs themselves. I searched the Web using Google’s search engine, saved the results on the social bookmarking site, del.icio.us, and began tagging Web pages with “blogs as scholarship” on July 23, 2007. Later, I set up a blog alert to notify me whenever anyone discusses blogs as scholarship on a blog. I received a notice on November 14, 2007, for example. Anne Reed, a practicing trial attorney, was reviewing a book and discussed in that context how blogging had changed the discussion between law professors and practitioners (2007). Reed believes that blogs are affecting legal scholarship. She thinks that the style of blog writing evidences a change in the goals of legal scholars. They want to communicate with a wider audience, an audience that includes her. They recognize that style matters, they consciously change their style, and this in turn has made legal theory more accessible to practitioners. Practitioners and professors now talk with each other. She tells a story of this change, in blog-style (pars. 4-6):

I began lots of articles. Over and over, I set them aside because they had nothing to do with the work I was doing, or the work anybody else was doing. ... Law professors and law practitioners had little to say to each other in those days [the 80's].

It's all different now. The change isn't entirely caused by the Internet; the focus of legal scholarship itself seems to have shifted toward the practical. (So that, for example, the Empirical Legal Studies Blog could present this week "a particularly exciting example of how empirical legal scholarship can illuminate important matters about how the judicial system actually operates.").

But at least as important, as far as I can tell, is that blogging has changed the way lawyers and professors talk to each other. Practitioners hear from professors daily, not when the quarterly review comes out. Professors hear from practitioners, instead of just each other. And whenever either side posts, the other side chimes in with comments. It's a discussion.

Judges on the Second Circuit court of appeals apparently feel the same way. Douglas Berman blogged about an article covering a conference at Cardozo School of Law in Spring 2007 where judges pleaded with law professors to write more plainly about subjects relevant to the judges (Berman, 2007; Liptak, 2007, par. 17): “If the academy does want to change the world,” Judge Reena Raggi said, “it does need to be part of the world.” Berman thinks blogs posts are responsive.

The substance of the blogospheric discussion of blogs as scholarship is not that different from the discussion in the traditional scholarly literature, recounted below; it is in form that the differences are pronounced. The form of a blog post is relatively short and lacks the careful phrasing (the weasel words) and, usually, the footnotes that a polished law review article will display. The idea that blog-style expands the audience for scholarly discourse is strongly thematic of the discussion on blogs and in the traditional literature. Research about information seeking supports the assertion that how we speak can facilitate the reader’s ability to relate new information to that which is already known and understood (Kuhlthau, 1991). Reed and the judges speaking out at Cardozo would agree.

On a related theme, many scholars say that different types of communication vehicles (blogs, presentations and academic papers, among many others) function differently for them, allowing them to express their ideas in different styles. Grainne Canole (2007) posted an entry on this subject on her blog, e4innovation.com. She also said that blogs allow researchers to reveal a more complete picture of what research is about -- the process, not just the results. Her post on this subject garnered many very interesting comments, most of whose authors take a similar position.

Sometimes blog post comments raise points that are equally as interesting as the blog post itself. Jodi Dean (2006) posted a short entry describing positive and negative aspects of typical blog characteristics (pars. 1-3) (the temporality of blogs, the community that develops around them, the question of whether blog-style might be good for academe), but within a long list of comments were ideas I had not seen elsewhere:

This form of writing encouraged me to express my ideas clearly by placing me in contact with individuals coming from very diverse backgrounds, and also forced me to think quickly on my feet in quick-time exchanges. In certain respects, I believe that this sort of exchange could be described as a sort of isometrics for the mind (Posted by: Levi | June 27, 2006 at 12:13 AM)

Illustrating the back-and-forth we will see in the traditional literature, Brian Leiter, author of Law school reports, posted an entry discussing why he was not attending the Bloggership symposium at Harvard Law School (described in more detail below) (2006, par. 1).

I didn't really want to attend a conference on what strikes me as a topic of no intellectual interest. *** I find it hard to see how blogs can have much significant scholarly impact when the most significant scholars rarely participate in the forum, or, at least, rarely participate for scholarly purposes.

Apparently, although Leiter does not enable comments on his blog, some of his colleagues may have communicated with him privately, because he updated his dour pronouncements the same day with links to two posts that he felt exemplified “[f]irst-rate stuff that anyone would have been proud to have written,” adding that the Internet made it possible to get the authors’ posts out quickly to a wide audience (par. 2). Further, in a more recent post, Leiter is much more sanguine about the importance of blogging, concluding his reflection on whether they help or hinder academics by noting that speaking out publicly on important matters is part of academic life (2007, par. 8).

The idea of blog as journal appears in the literature and the blogosphere. Dan Rodick, rethinking his own earlier questioning whether the opportunity cost of blogging (time not spent working on journal articles) was worth it, decided that he and his economics colleagues would likely continue to blog partly because of the “stunning” number of people who read their blogs, and because the blog acts as an important intellectual journal (Rodrik, 2007, pars. 4-5):

Not so incidentally, one of the unexpected scholarly benefits of having a blog is that it is like keeping an intellectual journal. You get an idea, you jot it down in your blog. Some months later, you vaguely remember having had the idea and you google your own blog to recover it. I am not kidding: I google my own blog all the time...

And here is the evidence: the first third of my talk at Nottingham was based on a couple of blog posts from a few weeks back (this and this).

References:

Berman, D. (2007). More grist for the blog-scholarship debate [Blog post]. Sentencing Law and Policy, March 19, 2007. Retrieved November 23, 2007, from http://sentencing.typepad.com/sentencing_law_and_policy/2007/03/more_grist_for_.html

Canole, G. (2007). The nature of academic discourse [Blog post]. e4innovation.com: E-learning innovation: research, evaluation, practice and policy. Retrieved November 1, 2007, from http://e4innovation.com/?p=45

Dean, J. (2006). Blogs and scholarship [Blog post]. i cite. Retrieved November 1, 2007, from http://jdeanicite.typepad.com/i_cite/2006/06/blogs_and_schol.html

Kuhlthau, C. C. (1991). Inside the search process: Information seeking from the user's perspective. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 42(5), 361-371.

Leiter, B. (2006). Blogs as scholarship: Conference at Harvard [Blog post]. Brian Leiter's Law School Reports, April 28, 2006. Retrieved November 3, 2007, from http://leiterlawschool.typepad.com/leiter/2006/04/blogs_as_schola.html

Leiter, B. (2007). Do blogs help or hinder professional prospects? [Blog post]. Brian Leiter's Law School Reports, November 12, 2007. Retrieved November 18, 2007, from http://leiterlawschool.typepad.com/leiter/2007/11/nothing-like-a-.html

Liptak, A. (2007, March 19, 2007). When rendering decisions, judges are finding law reviews irrelevant. New York Times, from http://select.nytimes.com/2007/03/19/us/19bar.html?_r=1&ex=1174363200&en=953fc2755a367cfd&ei=5121&oref=slogin

Reed, A. (2007). The future of reputation, part I [Blog post]. Deliberations, November 14, 2007. Retrieved November 14, 2007, from http://jurylaw.typepad.com/deliberations/2007/11/the-future-of-r.html

Rodrik, D. (2007). Why the econ-blogosphere is here to stay [Blog post]. Dani Rodrik's Weblog: Unconventional Thoughts on Economic Development and Globalization, October 19, 2007. Retrieved November 18, 2007, from http://rodrik.typepad.com/dani_rodriks_weblog/2007/10/two-things-happ.html

Monday, November 26, 2007

CO2Stats: Measuring a Site's Impact

So, I'm in the midst of data analysis on the blogging a draft experiment, very focused on little details like how many people visited which pages and stayed how long, right? Thinking, of course, that this is a good thing, that people come, that they see lots of pages, that they stay a long time. Well, guess what? It's a bad thing: CO2Stats: Measuring a Site's Impact. Yessir! Impact -- not in a good way. CO2 emissions.

What an eye-opener. I think of myself as pretty conscientious, but it had not even occurred to me that by trying to place things out there where people will see them, I am contributing to global warming. Well, it's incredibly obvious, now that I think about it. But here's a little widget that actually measures your blog's negative impact on the planet.

This paragraph could go on to rationalize why I shouldn't feel bad about this, but it won't. I do. I don't know why this should have brought home the importance of carbon offsets when nothing else really has (I've been studiously avoiding thinking about that whole game I suppose). Now it's personal. I am encouraging energy use (some might say frivolous energy use) by blogging. I need to do something about this. Now I need to find out the real truth about carbon offsetting. It just sounds too easy. I have a garden. Is that enough? I plant trees. I have a forest (1 acre of it anyway). Uh-oh. I'm rationalizing and I said I wouldn't. The bottom line is I have to find out what carbon offsetting is and how it works and get serious about taking responsibility for my actions.

Friday, November 23, 2007

Blogs as scholarship presentation; due in one week



Blogging on Peer-Reviewed ResearchI have been working for about 6 weeks now on the research project, blogs as scholarship, for my doctoral research and theory and radio, television and film studies classes. I'm just about finished with the lit review and analysis of future research; I must get busier with drafting the observations from my experiment at Mass Digitization. This weekend I'll set aside time to get that into at least a reasonable first draft. But for now, I need to prepare for the presentation on the lit review. The image above shows the concept map I created using cMaps Tools to talk about the relationships between the questions raised in the reports by bloggers, underlying values and beliefs, and different theories through which one might investigate further. Very cool tool. But in the mean time, I thought I might go ahead and serialize the paper in maybe 3 or 4 parts, plus the bibliography. Here's the opening:

Abstract

This survey of the discussion about whether legal blogs are a form of scholarly communication includes examples from the blogosphere (the term broadly applied to all blogs on the Internet), where discussion is quite informal, and traditional and new electronic-only forms of law review and journal literature. With few exceptions, the discussion reflects opinion and non-systematic observation. Nevertheless, seven themes emerge from discussion in both locations: 1) blogs and blogging enter existing arrays of types of communication media and academic duties and must find their utility in either replacing or extending existing forms; 2) blogging can be synergistic with other academic duties and forms of scholarship; 3) essential features of blogs include their short posts, timeliness, informal style and relatively broad audience; 4) blogs build communities of readers and can be used to solicit commentary for early-stage ideas; 5) blogs have disadvantages as well as advantages; 6) they are part of an emerging Web-based, computer mediated system for establishing scholarly authority; and 7) ultimately, they are not actually driving change, rather, they are one of many effects of a shift within academe towards shorter, more open forms of disintermediated communication.

The paper next suggests research questions based upon the emergent themes just described, the need to define the concepts and values embedded in the discussion of blogs as scholarship, such as the nature of information and the values traditional forms of literature evidence, and possible theoretical frameworks within which the phenomena might be examined, including a positivist approach, a material-semiotic approach (actor-network theory), neo-pragmatism and sociocultural theory, information behavior or practice, and boundary objects.

Introduction

I started blogging when I semi- retired from the practice of law and took up life as an academic. I now host four blogs, soon to be five. Blogging is tailor-made for explaining aspects of my legal specialty, copyright, to a non-legal audience. But as I consider my future academic publishing responsibilities, I wonder whether this particular communication medium might be more than merely fun. Might it be part of the process of establishing credentials as a scholar? My new career affords the opportunity to explore just such questions, and because I work in two worlds today, the law and social science, I can begin my research career by joining both in the study of legal scholarship from a social science perspective. Luckily, legal bloggers discuss whether their blogs are scholarship, so they create a self-identified group of bloggers to query, a collection of blog entries to study, and traditional scholarly literature to review.

Orin Kerr, whose views I will discuss later, defines legal scholarship as “research into and writing about the legal system in an attempt to shed light in an important and lasting way on the function, purposes, meaning, and impact of the legal system and role of law in society"(2006). The question of whether blogs are (or ever will be) legal scholarship is not academic. On the contrary, it is vitally important whether an activity that engages many legal scholars for hours each week will further their careers. Scholars thus discuss this question on their blogs, at conferences and in the journal literature. But with few exceptions, which I will review below, they do not theorize, construct models, test hypotheses, systematically observe anything or critically analyze scholarly communication. One could conclude that the absence of such features is merely characteristic of much of legal research reporting generally; however, I observed the same phenomenon in discourse on blogs as scholarship in fields other than law (Canole, 2007; Dean, 2006), and in discourse about the future of writing on the Internet generally (Serius, 2007).

Why study blogs? They are rather niche, and my interests are actually broader – the future of libraries in a networked world – but I have, little by little, accepted that the library’s future depends on just this kind of little thing. What I learn about legal blogging and its relationship to legal scholarship may tell me something about academic scholarship more broadly. But more importantly, studying legal blogging could reveal in the context of a particular communication mechanism (blogs) potentially far reaching effects of the ease with which anyone may reach a wider audience today than was possible when academic authors depended on publishers to distribute their works. Blogs are instant publishing, and instant publishing will likely do more than just publish instantly. It likely contributes to changes already taking place in the academic publishing industry, the communities of scholarly authors, and the systems of authority they depend upon to validate their work. Instant publishing enables legal scholars to reach an audience beyond the numbers and types of readers to which they were only recently limited by the small subscription bases for the journals in which they typically published. Authors must write differently for a broader public than for an insular academic audience. Writing for a broader public will have an effect on what the author writes and how it is expressed. I want to know what that effect might be and what its implications are for libraries.

For example, if any part of even some blogs might constitute scholarship, and if scholars’ use of academic blogs increases, academic libraries will need to assess how and to what extent they should collect and archive blogs (Dempsey, 2007, par. 14). Blogs locate a discourse within social networks where it is sometimes difficult to discern the contours of what we used to call a document, or a discussion. If top bloggers spend half their blogging time commenting on others’ blogs (O'Keefe, 2007), preserving blogged scholarship will likely pose interesting challenges for libraries and librarians. More fundamentally, if blogs are scholarly communication, they will compete with closed forms that communicate the same types of information, adding to the pressure on traditional scholarly publishers to take better advantage of the Web’s potential to enhance the speed, reach and effectiveness of scholarly communication. And, of course, when publishing changes, libraries change too.

References:

Canole, G. (2007). The nature of academic discourse [Blog post]. e4innovation.com: E-learning innovation: research, evaluation, practice and policy. Retrieved November 1, 2007, from http://e4innovation.com/?p=45

Dean, J. (2006). Blogs and scholarship [Blog post]. i cite. Retrieved November 1, 2007, from http://jdeanicite.typepad.com/i_cite/2006/06/blogs_and_schol.html

Dempsey, L. (2007). Quotes of the day (and other days?): Persistent academic discourse [Blog post]. Lorcan Dempsey's Weblog on Libraries, Services and Networks, October 28, 2007. Retrieved November 18, 2007, from http://orweblog.oclc.org/archives/001467.html

Kerr, O. S. (2006). Blogs and the legal academy. Paper presented at the Bloggership: How blogs are transforming legal scholarship. Retrieved October 12, 2007, from http://ssrn.com/paper=896994

O'Keefe, K. (2007). Top bloggers spend half blogging time commenting on other blogs [Blog post]. Real Lawyers Have Blogs, November 17, 2007. Retrieved November 18, 2007, from http://kevin.lexblog.com/2007/11/articles/marketing-your-blog/top-bloggers-spend-half-blogging-time-commenting-on-other-blogs/

Serius, R. (2007). Is the net good for writers? [Blog post]. Ten Zen Monkeys, October 5, 2007. Retrieved November 3, 2007, from http://www.10zenmonkeys.com/2007/10/05/is-the-net-good-for-writers/